Shock Horror... Carbonated Soft Drinks In Decline

No longer the main event?

Beverage Digest released its topline volume numbers for 2008... and CSD volume at the big beverage companies is declining.

Frankly this is not really news, its been a trend for a number of years but the news media has been all over this today (Atlanta Journal quoted above). The 2008 number is -3%, in line with most analyst expectations, driven by cola declines (again in line). Gainers are Red Bull, Hansen's and my old company - Dr Pepper Snapple.

It will be interesting to watch 2009 as prices of non-carbonated beverage become comparatively higher priced and CSDs become a better value. As Brand Manager of RC it used to be that a 3 Liter of RC had greater interaction with the price of milk in some markets... families are often just trying to put the best priced beverage on the table. This dynamic will also drive the growth of Private Label, which is now at a significant savings against branded CSDs.

Is this the death spiral for CSDs? Unlikely, but it does seem to confirm that a different era for the big beverage companies is here, where volume is no longer the main objective. Note that revenue for beverages increased 1% to almost $72B. A nice market if you can tap it...

Some Energy Drink Thoughts...

I often get questions about energy drinks, their future and who is winning. So here are some thoughts.

Red Bull - Its very interesting that they have moved away from their cartoon-based international campaign and into a US market, local personality campaign. Red Bull is a massive TV advertiser (over $50M a year) and this is a big departure for them. It signals that they believe the US market is different, and that they need to better market to their consumers here. The commercial above is both spectacular and personal, dimensionalizing "gives you wings" in a very aspirational way.



Monster - The cut over of distribution from the independent networks to CCE is still in progress, but it is interesting that there has been little innovation from the folks in Corona this year - save for their own entry into the energy shots - a segment in overkill already.

Rockstar - Another business in transition as it moves into PBG for distribution. Aside for some new sponsorships, again there has been little in the way of energy innovation. They will be hoping that a better aligned distribution system will help grow their business.

Overall the 10% growth that the category enjoyed in 2008 was higher than many expected. My feeling is that these products have become more mainstream, and will continue their growth as long as energy from communications and excitement from new ideas fuels the category. The issue may be that the momentum enjoyed by the Monster and Rockstar businesses may be mitigated within the portfolio selling selling constructs of CCE and PBG.

Maybe this is a year for Red Bull after losing share for 4 straight years. Time will tell!

A Rational Discussion Of Energy Drinks

Are energy drinks that bad for teens?

Big Red Boots is one of the many interesting bloggers on energy drinks in the interweb (also check out taurinerules.com and energyfiend.com) . He does unbiased reviews of the various alternatives out there, and published an interesting article on the subject today.

In the article he attempts to lay out the real risks associated with teens consuming energy drinks in an attempt to offset the normal press sensationalism that is associated with coverage of the category. Indeed google "energy drinks teens" and a succession of demonizing articles appear from all kinds of websites.

His net that the sugar in energy drinks is a bigger risk than the caffeine is absolutely correct: I hope that the article gets the coverage it deserves.

Tea is Now Bad For You... Or Not

Having worked for over a decade for Snapple as the benefits of tea as a potent source of anti-oxidants that may fight cancer and slow the aging process became broadly known (not that we could ever legally make those claims), it is with interest that I came across this story on tea from the BBC.

Apparently consuming hot tea (above 70 Centigrade - really hot) can increase the likelihood of throat cancer according to a study in Iran. But - read deeper in the article and you discover that these scientists believe that it is really the chugging of very hot drinks that distresses the lining of the throat, and increases the chance of carcinoma.

So... this is more about drinking scalding beverages rather than tea being bad for you, and begs the question whether the sensational headline about tea has any real relevance to the story.

But I guess this makes Iced Tea a more attractive option (cue cheering from Lipton, Snapple, AriZona, Nestea, Sweet Leaf, New Leaf etc etc).

Caffeine and Sports Performance

Kevin Pietersen, England cricketer obviously believes that caffeine helps.

There is a constant debate in the sports nutrition community: Does the stimulant effect of caffeine outweigh its diuretic effects?

Today's New York Times carries an article that says that caffeine can improve performance. Frankly that is not really news, but it does represent a change in approach from the normal "caffeine is bad" coverage that normally occurs.

It also has commentary from a specialist sports nutritionist saying that with the right amount of caffeine with regular use, the diuretic effect is diminished.



Take a walk through your local health club or GNC and you will discover any number of caffeine-based sports stimulants: Products like Redline, Spikeshooter and Endorush all seek to maximize performance through caffeine. For me, I cannot take too much caffeine before a game - I lose concentration: So it ends up being a personal preference.

Of my own sporting heros, Kevin Pietersen, England cricketer consumes vast amounts of Red Bull while on the field, his flapping arms signal to the dressing room that he needs another drink (gives you wings... geddit?). And the impact on him... well there is the natural talent but that also probably helps. (See KP wack a cricket ball here).

Its good to see a more reasonable approach to caffeine in the mainstream media. But it is interesting that the whole article ignores energy drinks, focusing on coffee and coca cola. Was that done intentionally? May be the food police can only be pushed so much...

Colonel Sanders + Pot Holes = Marketing Gold

The Colonel fills another pot hole in Louisville...

KFC has come up with a great way to make a difference in their local community; by sponsoring pot hole repairs, then stenciling a brand message on top (a message that will wash away with the rain).

Its a brilliant move - it helps their community with a service that benefits just about everyone. And turns a mundane inconvenience into a significant way to boost consumer goodwill.

My hope is that the road crews have their own colonel dressed up and working on the team. (Note that in the photo above, the colonel has been in charge of the stenciling - see the white chalk on his right boot.) That would really "commit to the bit" and push the envelope. Making pot hole repair event marketing. And imagine the merchanidisng opportunity on the traffic report - the KFC pot hole filling becomes an event!

I just hope other brands take the lead of KFC. Imagine a world where Ronald McDonald and the Hamburgler are sweeping streets, Mr Clean is scrubbing public restrooms, or Snuggle is helping people fold their smalls at laundrettes... Brilliant!

Recession Trends And Their Implications

Nielsen made a great presentation at the National Candy Association on March 5th, giving marketers an interesting view of the behavioral impact on consumers. If you can't be bothered to go through the presentation, here are a few cocktail party highlights...

• At home food and beverage consumption is increasing with non-grocery retailers driving at home food growth (Drug Stores, Dollar Stores, Mass retailers)
  
• Retail trips by consumers are down, but basket ring per trip is up.
• Coupon use is increasing as are private label offerings
• Discretionary retailers and categories are declining
  

My inference, consumers are becoming less impulsive and more calculated in how they are spending their cash. In effect they are shopping bargains, items that provide a bang for the buck and items that they perceive to generally improve their lives.

At the end of the article they highlight that investment during a recession often leads to an improved postion during the next growth phase.

Of course the only issue is having the confidence to get from here to there.